| |
Do
You Really Understand the Opposite Sex?
By Laureen Ricks, University of Florida
May
20, 2003
The
blame game is a typical device used in the battle of the sexes.
When Ms. Female and Mr. Male fight with each other they are likely
to make negative comments about the whole opposite gender.
"Men
are irksome, irritating and infuriating," says Ms. Female.
"As far as the east is from the west, so are women and my ability
to figure out them," says Mr. Male. "I will never understand
them."
Males
and females are different. This is not a new idea. No matter how
old you are, you have probably been baffled, confused and frustrated
in your attempts to interact with the opposite sex. However, in
You Just Don't Understand: Women and Men in Conversation, linguist
Debra Tanner attempts to demystify the myths and stereotypes surrounding
male and female relationships.
According
to Tannen, men and women are raised in different cultures, and therefore,
have difficulty in communicating with the opposite sex. Her book
delves into how we differ, why we differ, and how we can overcome
our differences in communicating so that we can have healthier and
better relationships with each other. She explores how the different
worlds we live in compel us to use different words and styles.
She
investigates many intriguing dynamics and questions: Why do women
tend to be quieter in public arenas, such as meetings and classrooms
but dominate the talk in small groups and at home? Why do men tend
to give a lecture when asked a "yes" or "no"
question? Why do men hate to ask for directions? Among other topics,
Tannen surveys interruptions, body language, gossip and conversation
dominance in the speech between men and women. She also deals with
issues of dominance, control and power structures involved in male
and female interaction.
According
to Tannen, few misunderstandings and sparks fly when males talk
to males and females talk to females. The reason is we understand
the world and language of our gender. However, males and females
perceive the world differently. Guys tend to see themselves in a
hierarchal pattern. They live in a social order or chain of command;
therefore, life is a contest, and conversations are negotiations
for status. They are trying to preserve their independence. Women,
however, tend to see themselves in a community and seek intimacy
and understanding. Therefore, conversations are negotiations for
support and consensus. These concepts, writes Tannen, are at the
heart of the misunderstandings and miscommunications that take place
between men and women.
For
example, a female might consult with someone before making a major
decision. Consulting is a sign of intimacy and respect. Tannen gives
the example of a woman who was frustrated when her husband did not
consult with her before making plans for the weekend with his friends.
"I shouldn't have to get permission from my wife," complained
the man. He felt that would be giving away some of his freedom.
His wife felt that his lack of communication with her was a sign
of lack of intimacy, and she felt threatened.
Another
common problem is how each gender deals with their problem. Females
discuss their problems, not in search of an answer but in search
of understanding and empathy. Other women recognize this fact and
are quick to support and sympathize with their female friends. Men,
however, can be irritated at what seems like women complaining and
not doing anything about their situation. Men are also frustrated
when their attempts at solving the problem bring resentment from
women. Men tend to want to solve the problems, but the woman wants
to receive understanding.
These
are just a few of the numerous examples in Tannen's book where both
genders interpret the same circumstance differently. Tannen writes
that understanding the gender differences helps people not to take
difficulty in communicating personally and not to place blame on
the entire opposite gender. Understanding these differences will
help women and men adjust and adapt to each other's styles.
Tannen's
book is geared towards a mature audience, i.e., married folks and
those in serious relationships. But the ideas in it are useful for
anyone who has at least a bare minimum of contact with the opposite
gender and wants to reduce the opportunities for mishaps and unnecessary
conflict. She has done extensive research, and her book is filled
with recorded conversations between men and women and between same-sex
speakers. These dialogues range from preschoolers to high schoolers
to middle-aged adults.
This
book is insightful, shedding light onto a befuddling topic. It also
takes into account the uniqueness of all individuals and different
communication styles according to race, age, class, profession,
personality, etc. Not only is this book a comprehensive guide to
understanding disparities between the sexes, but it is also very
funny. It is amusing to read the dialogues between males and females
and see the same misunderstandings that you have experienced.
|